Toft’s Ice Cream

Beyond Measure Market proudly serves our clients with Toft’s Quality Ice cream. First starting in the early 1900’s, Toft’s Ice cream is Ohio Oldest Ice Cream and is still made locally in Sandusky, Ohio today. 

From classics like Chocolate and Vanilla, to new favorites like Blueberry Waffle Cone and Buckeye Bites, there’s something for everyone!



  • One half gallon – $4.79
  • Two or more half gallons – $3.99/each

3-Gallon Tub:

  • Range from $39.99 – $49.99
    (Depending on Flavor)

Cake Cone:

  • One Scoop – $2.00   
  • Two Scoops – $2.50
  • Three Scoops – $3.00

Waffle Cone:

  • One Scoop – $3.25   
  • Two Scoops – $3.75
  • Three Scoops – $4.25


  • One Scoop – $1.50   
  • Two Scoops – $2.00
  • Three Scoops – $2.50

Kiddie Cone:

  • One Scoop – $1.00

Signature Brand (Homemade):

Homemade Ice Cream

"One Quality" Ice Cream Boxes:

No Sugar Added Vanilla
French Vanilla
Rocky Road
Cookies ‘n Cream
Butter Pecan
Cookie Dough
Mint Choco Chip
Vanilla Chocolate Chunk
Yellow Cake Batter
Birthday Cake
Tin Roof Sundae
Super Duper Scoop
Peanut Butter Cup
Muddy’s Sea Salt Slam
Campfire S’mores
Double Choc. Almond
Cherry Vanilla
Blueberry Waffle Cone
Black Sweet Cherry
Pumpkin Pie
Holiday Peppermint
Lake Erie Cookie Island Monster
Cedar Point Cotton Candy

Prime Time Ice Cream Tubs:

Denali Vanilla Bean
Moose Tracks
Chocolate Moose Tracks
Chocolate Cookie Mint Madness
Banana Peanut Butter Chunk
Buckeye Bites
Caveman Chocolate
Cherry Amaretto Fudge
Plastered Praline Pecan
Black Raspberry Chocolate Chunk
Salty Caramel Fudge Truffle
Brown Butter Bourbon Truffle
Brownie Bandit
Maple Fudge Waffle Cone
Peanut Butter Cheesecake

Sherbet Tubs:

Rainbow Sherbet
Orange Sherbet
Triple Raspberry Sherbet
Tropical Sherbet


Flavors available only by the half gallon:

  • Orange Sherbet
  • Tropical Sherbet
  • Rainbow Sherbet
  • Triple Raspberry Sherbet
  • Caveman Chocolate
  • Brown Butter Bourbon Truffle
  • Chocolate Moose Tracks
  • Moose Tracks
  • Salty Caramel Fudge Truffle
  • Black Raspberry Chocolate Chunk
  • Maple Fudge Waffle Cone
  • Chocolate Cookie Mint Madness
  • Peanut Butter Cheesecake
  • Cherry Vanilla
  • Yellow Cake Batter
  • Neapolitan
  • Cookie Dough
  • Cookies ‘n Cream
  • Vanilla Chocolate Chunk
  • Rocky Road
  • Butter Pecan
  • Double Chocolate Almond
  • Birthday Cake
  • Lake Erie Cookie Island Monster
  • Super Duper Scoop
  • Cedar Point Cotton Candy

Flavors available by the scoop and half gallon:

  • Black Cherry
  • Holiday Peppermint
  • Blueberry Waffle Cone
  • Orange Sherbet
  • Vanilla
  • Peanut Butter Cup
  • Chocolate
  • Sugar Free Vanilla
  • Strawberry
  • Mint Chocolate Chip

Flavors available by 3-gallon tub:

  • Orange Sherbet
  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Mint Chocolate Chip
  • Blueberry Waffle Cone
  • Rocky Road
  • Black Sweet Cherry
  • Caramel Espresso Chip
  • Butter Pecan
  • Butter Pecan Crunch