Skip to content
Winter Sales
Deli Sales
Join our Team
Hours and Directions
Contact Us
Sign Up for Alerts
Our Mission
Cafe & Deli
Shop
Catering
Products search
Cart
0
Winter Sales
Deli Sales
Join our Team
Hours and Directions
Contact Us
Navigation Menu
Navigation Menu
Our Mission
Cafe & Deli
Shop
Catering
Close
Home
\
Product shipping classes
\
Local Pickup
Showing all 38 results
Default sorting
Sort by popularity
Sort by average rating
Sort by latest
Sort by price: low to high
Sort by price: high to low
Cubed Cheese – 3 Flavor Variety
$
10.99
Cubed Cheese – Variety 5 Flavors
$
18.99
Fry Pies
$
2.99
Noodles – Amish Wedding with Chicken (1 lb)
$
4.39
Bread – White
$
4.29
Bread – Wheat
$
4.29
Bread – Rye
$
5.29
Bread – Raisin
$
5.29
Bread – Banana Nut
$
4.29
Bread – Banana
$
3.99
Bread – Apple Pecan
$
4.29
Bread – Apple
$
3.99
Cake – Blueberry
$
7.29
Cake – Triple Berry
$
7.29
Cookies – Chocolate Whoopie Pies (4 Pack)
$
5.99
Cookies – Oatmeal Whoopie Pies (4 Pack)
$
5.99
Cookies – No-Bakes (Chocolate Peanut Butter)
$
3.99
Cheesecake – Cherry
$
3.99
Cheesecake – Red Raspberry
$
3.99
Cheesecake – Blueberry
$
3.99
Cheesecake – Strawberry
$
3.99
Parfait – Vanilla
$
3.99
Parfait – Buckeye
$
3.99
Parfait – Peanut Butter
$
3.99
Parfait – Dirt Pudding
$
3.99
Buckeyes (Milk Chocolate) – Four
$
3.25
Buckeyes (Dark Chocolate) – Four
$
3.25
Clusters – Milk Chocolate Pretzel Peanut (1 lb)
$
12.99
Clusters – White Chocolate Pretzel Peanut (1 lb)
$
12.99
Graham Crackers – Dark Chocolate (1 lb)
$
12.99
Peanut Butter Delights – Dark Chocolate (1 lb)
$
12.99
Peanut Butter Delights – Milk Chocolate (1 lb)
$
12.99
Peanut Butter Delights – White Chocolate (1 lb)
$
12.99
Pretzels – Chocolate Mix (1 lb)
$
12.99
Pretzels – Dark Chocolate (1 lb)
$
12.99
Pretzels – Milk Chocolate (1 lb)
$
12.99
Pretzels – White Chocolate (1 lb)
$
12.99
White Trash (1 lb)
$
5.99