Skip to content
Weekly Deli Sales
Events
Join Our Team
Hours and Directions
Contact Us
Sign up for Alerts
Home
Our Mission
Cafe and Deli
Shop
Products search
Cart
0
Navigation Menu
Navigation Menu
Home
Our Mission
Cafe and Deli
Shop
Close
Home
\
Product shipping classes
\
Local Pickup
Showing all 23 results
Default sorting
Sort by popularity
Sort by average rating
Sort by latest
Sort by price: low to high
Sort by price: high to low
Banana Nut Bread Homemade
$
4.29
Peanut Butter – Esther’s Amish Homemade (10 oz)
$
5.99
Peanut Butter – Esther’s Amish Homemade (18 oz)
$
7.99
Buckeyes (Dark Chocolate) – Four
$
3.25
Buckeyes (Milk Chocolate) – Four
$
3.25
Graham Crackers (Dark Chocolate) – 1 Pound
$
9.99
Peanut Butter Delights (Dark Chocolate) – 1 Pound
$
12.99
Pretzels (Dark Chocolate) – 1 Pound
$
12.99
Choco PB No-bake Cookies
$
3.99
Chocolate Whoopie Pies (4 Pack)
$
5.99
Fruit Trays
$
43.99
–
$
63.99
Oatmeal Whoopie Pies (4 Pack)
$
5.99
White Bread Homemade
$
4.29
Fry Pies
$
2.99
Meat Lover’s Tray
$
37.99
–
$
63.99
The Beyond Deluxe
$
41.99
–
$
63.99
The Beyond Tray
$
41.99
–
$
63.99
Vegetable Trays
$
29.99
–
$
42.99
Cheese Cube Snacker
$
31.99
–
$
55.99
Deluxe Cheese Tray
$
34.99
–
$
49.99
Sliced Cheese Tray
$
37.99
–
$
53.99
Pin Wheel Tray
$
27.99
–
$
46.99
Sub Tray
$
35.99
–
$
44.99
