Skip to content

Beyond Measure Market is a Market on a Mission…online!

Now, you can support our mission from the comfort of your own home! We’ll ship what we can directly to your door, anywhere in the United States. Items that are available for pickup only are marked clearly. 

 For questions, just call us and let us know how we can help.

Best Sellers

For your convenience, our most popular items are listed below.  Click on any for a fast and friendly online shopping experience.  

40 lb Case of Chicken

Dark Rye Flour

Homemade Buckeyes

Fry Pies

Deli Trays

Shop Local

Most products below are only available for in-store pickup.

Baked Goods:

Fresh Pies

Homemade Bread

Chocolate Whoopie Pies

Oatmeal Whoopie Pies

Candy and Chocolates:

Homemade Buckeyes

Peanut Butter Delights

Chocolate Covered Graham Crackers

Chocolate Covered Pretzels


A Taste of Amish Cooking

Gift Cards

Gift Basket – Large

Gift Box

Available for Shipping

Most Products below are available for shipping or in-store pickup.

Jarred Goods:

Apple Sauce

Apple Butter

Pasta Sauce

Mild Salsa

Bulked Foods:

King Arthur Special Flour

Strawberry Cheesecake Peanuts

Mixed Nuts – Butter Toffee

Bean Redeemed Coffee

Beef Jerky:

Beef Sticks – Original

Beef Sticks – Honey

Beef Jerky – Maple

Beef Jerky – Barbeque

Health and Beauty:

B&W Salve

Elderberry Honey Syrup

Two Gals and a Goat Soap – Baby Fresh

Two Gals and a Goat Lotion – Pearberry


Popcorn – Ladyfinger

Steins Honey – 32 oz

Italian Wedding Soup Mix

Extra Wide Noodles

Best of all, everything you buy from the Beyond Measure Market, even online, helps in our efforts to provide safe transition to the former Amish into our English culture.

Learn more about MAP Ministry and find more ways you can help support our important mission.