Skip to content
Home
Shop Online
Local Pickup
Cafe
Deli
Deli Trays
Sack Lunches
Fresh Pies
Baked Goods and Chocolates
Fry Pies
Fresh Chicken Breasts (40 lb)
Careers
About Us
Our Story
FAQ
Hours & Contact Us
0 items
Navigation Menu
Navigation Menu
Home
Shop Online
Local Pickup
Cafe
Deli
Deli Trays
Sack Lunches
Fresh Pies
Baked Goods and Chocolates
Fry Pies
Fresh Chicken Breasts (40 lb)
Careers
About Us
Our Story
FAQ
Hours & Contact Us
0 items
Pre-Order
Handmade Soaps by Bob Miller – Grand Pappy
$
4.59
Handmade Soaps by Bob Miller – Lavendar
$
4.59
Handmade Soaps by Bob Miller – Patchoul
$
4.59
Handmade Soaps by Bob Miller – Urban Cowboy
$
4.59
Lye Soap – Citrus Blend
$
4.59
Lye Soap – Honey Oatmeal Goat Milk
$
4.59
Lye Soap – Lavender
$
4.59
Lye Soap – Lemongrass Soap
$
4.59
Lye Soap – Rosemary Lavender with Charcoal
$
4.59
Two Gals and a Goat Soap – Baby Fresh
$
6.99
Two Gals and a Goat Soap – Breezes and Sunshine
$
6.99
Two Gals and a Goat Soap – Cherry Almond
$
6.99
Two Gals and a Goat Soap – Doodlebug
$
6.99
Two Gals and a Goat Soap – Orange Creamsicle
$
6.99
Two Gals and a Goat Soap – Pearberry
$
6.99
Two Gals and a Goat Soap – Twelve
$
6.99
Two Gals and a Goat Soap – Unscented
$
6.99
Two Gals and a Goat Homemade Lotion – Black Raspberry Vanilla
$
6.99
Two Gals and a Goat Homemade Lotion – Cherry Almond
$
6.99
Two Gals and a Goat Homemade Lotion – Coconut Creme
$
6.99
Two Gals and a Goat Homemade Lotion – Grapefruit Lemon
$
6.99
Two Gals and a Goat Homemade Lotion – Magnolia and Orange
$
6.99
Two Gals and a Goat Homemade Lotion – Pearberry
$
6.99
B&W Salve – 4 oz
$
11.29
B&W Salve – 8 oz
$
21.29
Union Salve – 3.5 oz
$
6.99
Union Salve – 7 oz
$
10.69
Deep Penetrating Pain Relief Cream – 1 oz
$
3.79
Deep Penetrating Pain Relief Cream – 3.5 oz
$
10.59
Deep Penetrating Pain Relief Cream – 7 oz
$
17.69
Herbal Extract – Adrenal Support
$
28.29
Herbal Extract – Bowel Reg
$
26.99
Herbal Extract – Bowel Stim
$
14.99
Herbal Extract – Brighter Mornings
$
12.59
Herbal Extract – Calm/Nerve
$
26.99
Herbal Extract – CBD 200mg Reg Strength
$
16.69
Herbal Extract – CBD 750mg Super Strength
$
48.99
Herbal Extract – Cramp Bark
$
15.99
Herbal Extract – Dental Formula
$
23.59
Herbal Extract – Digestive Tonic
$
27.89
Herbal Extract – Echinacea Goldenseal
$
16.99
Herbal Extract – Ech-N-Elder
$
15.99
Herbal Extract – Heart
$
25.49
Herbal Extract – Healthy Gums
$
15.99
Herbal Extract – Healthy Veins
$
26.99
Herbal Extract – Herb Calc
$
21.99
Herbal Extract – Ivy Oaky/Jewelweed
$
30.99
Herbal Extract – Joint Health
$
23.99
Herbal Extract – Kidney/Bladder (4 oz)
$
15.99
Herbal Extract – Adapto-munity
$
15.99
Herbal Extract – Aller Out
$
14.29
Herbal Extract – Kidney/Bladder (8 oz)
$
28.49
Mushroom Immune
$
16.69
Herbal Extract – Ladies Formula
$
28.59
Herbal Extract – Liver Formula
$
27.99
Herbal Extract – Lymph Move
$
16.89
Herbal Extract – Milk Plus
$
26.99
Herbal Extract – Mullein Garlic Oil
$
10.99
Herbal Extract – Natural Sleep
$
27.99
Herbal Extract – Para-Cleanse
$
24.99
Herbal Extract – Prostate Health
$
16.99
Herbal Extract – Respiratory Aid
$
24.99
Herbal Extract – Stone Breaker
$
14.99
Herbal Extract – Sugar Balance
$
27.99
Herbal Extract – Super Tonic
$
21.99
Herbal Extract – Tasty Attention
$
15.99
Herbal Extract – Tasty Calm
$
15.99
Herbal Extract – Tasty Dry Bed
$
12.99
Herbal Extract – Tasty Echinacea
$
14.99
Herbal Extract – Tasty Elderberry Immune
$
15.99
Herbal Extract – Tasty Paracleanse
$
15.99
Herbal Extract – Throat and Tonsil
$
25.99
Herbal Extract – Thyroid Support
$
26.99
Herbal Extract – Tummy Calm
$
12.99
Herbal Extract – Yeast/Candida
$
15.99
Oil – Arnica
$
11.59
Beyond Measure Market Gift Card
$
10.00
–
$
100.00
Oil – Deep Tissue
$
13.39
Gift Baskets
$
34.99
–
$
99.99
Taste of Amish Cooking
$
18.00
Swan Creek Candle Co. Candles
$
13.99
–
$
21.99
Local Handmade Cutting Boards
$
31.99
–
$
55.99
“Amazing Grace How Sweet The Sound” 44″ Sonnet Chime
$
88.99
“Angels’ Arms” 55″ Sonnet Chime
$
137.99
“Comfort & Light” 44″ Rose Gold Sonnet Chime
$
88.99
“Faith, Family, Friends” 30″ Sonnet Chime
$
52.99
“Faith” 35″ Vintage Chime
$
43.99
“Family” 44″ Sonnet Chime
$
88.99
“Footprints in the Sand” 44″ Sonnet Chime
$
84.99
“How Great Thou Art” 44″ Sonnet Chime
$
87.99
“Old Rugged Cross” 55″ Sonnet Chime
$
137.99
“Serenity Prayer” 30″ Sonnet Chime
$
49.99
“With the Angels” 44″ Sonnet Chime
$
88.99
Bean Redeemed Coffee (1 lb)
$
10.29
Brewd Awakening Coffee (1 lb)
$
10.29
Dream Bean Decaf Coffee (1 lb)
$
10.29
Ephesians 5:14 Coffee (1 lb)
$
10.29
Jehova Java Coffee (1 lb)
$
10.29
Pewter Fleck 44″ Signature Series Chime
$
79.99
Pewter Fleck 50″ Signature Series Chime
$
124.99
Sacred Grounds Coffee (1 lb)
$
10.29
Sand Fleck 50″ Signature Series Chime
$
121.99
5 Layer Delight Bar
$
1.99
Apple Butter (9 oz)
$
4.59
Apple Butter (19 oz)
$
5.29
Apple Butter – Sugar Free (9 oz)
$
3.99
Apple Butter – Sugar Free (19 oz)
$
5.29
Apple Pie Jam (19 oz)
$
6.99
Almonds – Whole, Roasted, Salted (1 lb)
$
7.49
Almonds – Sliced Natural Raw (1 lb)
$
7.29
Almonds – Smokehouse (1 lb)
$
8.49
Almonds – Cinnamon Roasted (1 lb)
$
7.99
Almonds – Blueberry (1 lb)
$
11.29
Applesauce – Cinnamon (32 oz)
$
5.49
Applesauce – Honeycrisp (32 oz)
$
5.49
Applesauce – No Sugar Added (32 oz)
$
5.49
Bartlett Pears (32 oz)
$
8.99
BBQ Sauce – Original (17 oz)
$
5.99
Beets – Pickled Baby (17 oz)
$
5.49
Beets – Pickled Baby (32 oz)
$
7.99
Black Raspberry Seedless Jam (9 oz)
$
4.69
Black Raspberry Jam – Sugar Free (9 oz)
$
5.99
Blackberry Jam – Sugar Free (9 oz)
$
5.29
Blackberry Jam (9 oz)
$
4.69
Walnut Creek Noodles – Medium
$
2.69
Walnut Creek Noodles – Wide
$
2.69
Walnut Creek Noodles – Extra Wide
$
2.69
Blackberry Jam (19 oz)
$
6.99
Walnut Creek Noodles – Kluski
$
2.69
Walnut Creek Noodles – Pot Pie Squares
$
2.69
Walnut Creek Noodles – Spinach
$
2.69
Walnut Creek Noodles – Whole Wheat
$
2.69
Walnut Creek Noodles – Garlic Parsley
$
2.69
Gluten Free Noodles – Egg
$
5.59
Blueberry Jam (9 oz)
$
4.69
Blueberry Jam (19 oz)
$
6.99
Sanded Drops – Assorted Fruit
$
1.59
Christmas Jam (9 oz)
$
4.69
Christmas Jam (18 oz)
$
6.99
Banana Nut Bread Homemade
$
4.29
Concord Grape Jelly (19 oz)
$
6.99
Eggs – Jalapeno (32 oz)
$
8.59
Eggs – Pickled (32 oz)
$
7.29
Eggs – Pickled Beet (32 oz)
$
8.59
Black Raspberry Jelly (19 oz)
$
9.59
Pear Jam (19 oz)
$
6.99
Red Raspberry Jelly (19 oz)
$
6.99
Strawberry Jelly (19 oz)
$
6.99
Elderberry Jam (19 oz)
$
6.99
Beef Jerky – Original (3.25 oz)
$
6.89
Beef Jerky – Barbeque (3.25 oz)
$
6.89
Beef Jerky – Barbeque (14.5 oz)
$
21.99
FROG Jam (19 oz)
$
6.99
Beef Jerky – Maple (3.25 oz)
$
6.89
Beef Jerky – Maple (14.5 oz)
$
21.99
Beef Jerky – Spicy Hot (3.25 oz)
$
6.89
Garlic – Sweet Pickled (17 oz)
$
8.29
Beef Jerky – Spicy Hot (14.5 oz)
$
21.99
Okra – Hot Pickled (16 oz)
$
4.69
Okra – Hot Pickled (32 oz)
$
5.99
Hot Pepper Jam (9 oz)
$
4.69
Orange Marmalade Jam (19 oz)
$
6.99
Beef Jerky – Teriyaki (3.25 oz)
$
6.89
Beef Jerky – Teriyaki (14.5 oz)
$
21.99
Pasta Sauce (17 oz)
$
3.99
Beef Jerky – Teriyaki (2 lbs)
$
41.39
Beef Jerky – Black Pepper (3.25 oz)
$
6.89
Peach Jam (9 oz)
$
4.69
Peach Jam – Sugar Free (9 oz)
$
5.29
Peach Jalapeno Jam (19 oz)
$
6.99
Beef Jerky – Black Pepper (14.5 oz)
$
21.99
Peaches – Halves (32 oz)
$
8.99
Beef Jerky – Habanero (3.25 oz)
$
6.89
Beef Jerky – Habanero (14.5 oz)
$
21.99
Peanut Butter – Esther’s Amish Homemade (10 oz)
$
5.99
Peanut Butter – Esther’s Amish Homemade (18 oz)
$
7.99
Beef Jerky – Raspberry Jalapeno (14.5 oz)
$
21.99
Beef Sticks – Original (14.5 oz)
$
12.99
Pickles – Bread and Butter (17 oz)
$
4.99
Pickles – Bread and Butter (32 oz)
$
7.29
Pickles – Dill Spears (17 oz)
$
5.29
Beef Sticks – Original (36 oz)
Rated
5.00
out of 5
$
23.89
Beef Sticks – Orginal (2 lbs)
$
41.39
Beef Sticks – Honey (14.5 oz)
$
12.99
Beef Sticks – Honey (36 oz)
$
23.89
Beef Sticks – Chipotle Cheddar (14.5 oz)
$
11.99
Pickles – Sweet Garlic Dill (17 oz)
$
4.99
Beef Sticks – Chipotle Cheddar (36 oz)
$
23.89
Pumpkin Butter (17 oz)
$
5.69
Pumpkin Butter (9 oz)
$
4.59
Beef Sticks – Spicy Hot (14.5 oz)
$
12.99
Beef Sticks – Spicy Hot (36 oz)
$
23.89
Beef Sticks – Spicy Hot (2 lbs)
$
41.39
Red Raspberry Jam – Seedless (19 oz)
$
6.99
Relish – Bread and Butter (17 oz)
$
4.59
Relish – Corn (14 oz)
$
4.59
Relish – Green Tomato (17 oz)
$
4.59
Rhubarb Jam (19 oz)
$
6.99
Buckeye Chocolate Bar
$
1.99
Buckeyes (Milk Chocolate) – Homemade
$
3.25
Salsa – Black Bean (17 oz)
$
5.29
Caramel Pecan Turtle
$
1.99
Salsa – Medium Hot (17 oz)
$
5.69
Salsa – Mild (17 oz)
$
5.99
Salsa – Pineapple (17 oz)
$
5.99
Cashews – Whole Medium 320, Roasted, Salted (1 lb)
$
9.49
Asparagus – Pickled Spears (16 oz)
$
7.29
Banana Pepper Rings (Mild) – 16 oz
$
4.29
Sauerkraut (32 oz)
$
6.29
Cashews – Whole Medium 320, Roasted, Unsalted (1 lb)
$
8.29
Cashews – Honey Roasted, Whole (1 lb)
$
10.99
Cashews – Butter Toffee (1 lb)
$
8.29
Cashews – White Chocolate Flavored (1 lb)
$
10.99
Mixed Nuts – Danny’s Sweet Delight (1 lb)
$
7.79
Mixed Nuts – Sweet and Spicy (1 lb)
$
6.59
Mixed Nuts – Butter Toffee (1 lb)
$
7.29
Peanuts – Roasted, Salted, In the Shell (1 lb)
$
3.79
Peanuts – Spanish No. 1, Roasted, Salted, Shelled (1 lb)
$
3.29
Peanuts – Blanched, Roasted, Salted, Shelled (1 lb)
$
3.49
Peanuts – Cheddar Jalapeno (1 lb)
$
5.39
Peanuts – Hot Pepper (1 lb)
$
3.29
Peanuts – Butter Rum (1 lb)
$
4.79
Peanuts – Creme (1 lb)
$
4.69
Sour Cherry Jam (19 oz)
$
6.99
Salve – Chickweed and Plantain
$
17.99
Southern Mild Chow Chow (17 oz)
$
4.79
Choco PB No-bake Cookies
$
3.99
Chocolate Whoopie Pies (4 Pack)
$
5.99
Peanuts – Strawberry Cheesecake (1 lb)
$
4.69
Peanuts – Redskin Roasted, Salted, Shelled (1 lb)
$
2.99
Peanuts – French (1 lb)
$
4.49
Pecan Pieces – Medium (1 lb)
$
8.49
Pecans – Halves, Roasted, Unsalted (1 lb)
$
13.99
Pecans – Honey Roasted (1 lb)
$
14.49
Pecans – Cinnamon Roasted (1 lb)
$
14.89
Pecans – Buttered, Halves (1 lb)
$
13.29
Strawberry Jam (9 oz)
$
4.69
Strawberry Jam (19 oz)
$
6.99
Cinnamon Roll – Maple Icing
$
3.49
Strawberry Jam – Sugar Free (9 oz)
$
5.29
Cinnamon Roll – Vanilla Icing
$
3.49
Cinnamon Rolls – Maple Icing
$
7.49
Strawberry Rhubarb Jam (19 oz)
$
6.99
Cinnamon Rolls – Vanilla Icing
$
7.49
Sweet Mustard (9 oz)
$
3.69
Coconut Dream Bar
$
1.99
Salve – Comfrey Salve
$
15.59
Salve – Resp-Eze
$
16.99
Traffic Jam (9 oz)
$
4.69
Salve – Complete Tissue
$
20.39
Salve – Deep Tissue
$
19.99
Salve – Garlic
$
18.49
Traffic Jam (19 oz)
$
6.99
Triple Berry Jam (19 oz)
$
6.99
Fresh Chicken Breasts (40 lb)
$
10.00
(Deposit)
Fruit Trays
$
43.99
–
$
63.99
Gluten Free Noodles – Garlic Parsley
$
7.29
Gluten Free Noodles – High Fiber
$
6.29
Gluten Free Noodles – Medium Egg Noodles
$
6.29
Gluten Free Noodles – Tomato Basil
$
5.99
Soup Mix – Classic Chicken Noodle
$
9.49
Soup Mix – Creamy Chicken Noodle
Rated
5.00
out of 5
$
9.49
Soup Mix – Creamy Mushroom
$
9.49
Soup Mix – Creamy Potato
$
9.49
Salve – Herbal Black
$
8.69
Herbal Extract – Elderberry Honey Syrup
$
18.49
Herbal Iron Syrup
$
26.99
Herbal Throat Spray
$
11.49
Walnut Halves & Pieces Combo (1 lb)
$
6.49
Walnuts – Halves and Pieces, Raw (1 lb)
$
5.59
Raw Brazil Nuts – Midget Redskin (1 lb)
$
9.69
Homemade White Trash (1 lb)
$
5.99
Homemade Monkey Munch (1 lb)
$
3.99
Homemade Party Mix (1 lb)
$
7.59
Hotel and Restaurant All Purpose Flour (1 lb)
$
0.89
King Arthur Special Flour (1 lb)
$
0.99
Dark Rye Flour (1 lb)
$
0.79
Soup Mix – Italian Wedding
$
9.49
Soup Mix – Corn Chowder
$
9.49
Jewelweed Spray
$
8.99
Slippery Elm
$
20.69
Soup Mix – White Bean Chicken Chili
$
9.49
Soup Mix – Stuffed Pepper
$
9.49
Maple Syrup – 1 Gallon
$
56.99
Maple Syrup – Half Gallon
$
34.49
Maple Syrup – Quart
$
21.49
Maple Syrup – Pint
$
11.99
Mocha Pecan Milk Chocolate
$
1.99
Oatmeal Whoopie Pies (4 Pack)
$
5.99
Occident Unbleached Bromated Flour (1 lb)
$
0.89
Pie and Pastry Flour (1 lb)
$
0.79
Sir Galahad Artisan Unbleached All Purpose Flour (1 lb)
$
0.89
Peanut Butter Milk Chocolate Turtle
$
1.99
Peanut Butter Mini S’more Bar
$
1.99
Pecan Caramel Roll
$
0.49
People’s Paste Powder (0.5 oz)
$
6.49
People’s Paste Powder (2 oz)
$
11.39
Sanded Drops – Peppermint
$
1.59
Sea Salt Caramel Chocolate Bar
$
1.99
Sea Salt Caramel Roll
$
0.49
Sea Salt Cashew Cluster
$
1.99
Sea Salt Peanut Cluster
$
1.99
Shelby Joes Sauce – Sweet
$
5.99
Mustard – Simply Sweet
$
4.99
Mustard – Simply Peppered
$
4.49
Mustard – Simply Chipotle
$
4.99
Mustard – Simply Horsey
$
4.99
Mustard – Simply Maple
$
4.99
Stein’s Honey – Cream
$
12.49
Stein’s Honey – 12 oz
$
6.99
Stein’s Honey – 16 oz
$
12.49
Stein’s Honey – 32 oz
$
13.99
Stein’s Honey – 5 lbs
$
32.99
Comb Honey
$
18.99
Mike’s Hot Honey
$
11.49
White Bread Homemade
$
4.29
White Dinner Rolls
$
5.29
Wild Cherry Honey Syrup
$
16.49
Fry Pies
$
2.99
Fresh Pies
$
10.49
–
$
16.49
Meat Lover’s Tray
$
37.99
–
$
63.99
The Beyond Deluxe
$
41.99
–
$
63.99
The Beyond Tray
$
41.99
–
$
63.99
Vegetable Trays
$
29.99
–
$
42.99
Cheese Cube Snacker
$
31.99
–
$
55.99
Deluxe Cheese Tray
$
34.99
–
$
49.99
Sliced Cheese Tray
$
37.99
–
$
53.99
Pin Wheel Tray
$
27.99
–
$
46.99
Sub Tray
$
35.99
–
$
44.99
Farm Dust Seasoning
$
5.29
Farm Dust Seasoning – No Salt
$
5.29
Farm Dust Seasoning – Spicy
$
5.29
Farm Dust Seasoning – Weavers
$
4.39
Sanded Drops – Cinnamon
$
1.59
Farm Dust Seasoning – Southwestern
$
5.29
Farm Dust Seasoning – Smokehouse Meat
$
5.29
Farm Dust Seasoning – Steak
$
5.29
Farm Dust Seasoning – Smoky Apple Orchard
$
6.29
Sanded Drops – Horehound
$
1.59
Farm Dust Seasoning – Original Grilling Sampler
$
11.79
Sanded Drops – Root Beer Drops
$
1.59
Sanded Drops – Anise
$
1.59
Sanded Drops – Watermelon
$
1.59
Sanded Drops – Lemon
$
1.59
Sanded Drops – Green Apple
$
1.59
Sanded Drops – Licorice
$
1.59
Caramel Popcorn Glaze
$
4.29
Popcorn Topping Buttery
$
4.29
Popcorn – Red
$
2.79
Popcorn – Rainbow
$
2.79
Nutritional Yeast Seasoning
$
7.79
Popcorn – White Baby Hulless
$
2.79
Popcorn – White Medium Hulless
$
2.79
Popcorn – Ladyfinger Hulless
$
3.29
Popcorn – Extra Large Caramel
$
3.49
Popcorn – White Burlap Hulless
$
3.49
Popcorn – Yellow Burlap
$
3.49
